Hmm...this was another weird one. I finished it last night (right before it won a Printz Honor) and once again, I'm on the fence. I really like the story and how it was told. However, I kind of hated it at the same time. I didn't really like the way Min, the narrator, spoke and everything was "you said this" "you did this"...I don't know. For me, it made it harder to concentrate on what was happening. I like the way Min told the story of her relationship with Ed through a box full of objects acquired while they dated. Overall the story was good and got better as it went along. I almost think my favorite thing about the book was that the pages were shiny and kind of smelled like a yearbook.